贴个imdb的TROY评论 －批评电影，表演开花

月月

以下是引用浊酒在2004-5-13 1:46:24的发言：
[quote]以下是引用orchi在2004-5-13 1:40:49的发言：
美男只该天上有，人间哪得几回见，见到就要打十年
  

最绝的最后一句:见到就要打十年
俺又开始多重理解:

正解是"像TROY战争一样,打个十年"
歪解是"见到开花这等美男,不暴打开花他十年--------------真是浪费"

------------流成吉思汗,俺快被暴打了

[em11][em11]

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-5-13 1:47:22编辑过]

[/quote]

别呀，看把小孩吓得，乖乖到姐姐这来，偶罩你十年。

浊酒

那当然,越爱越虐是俺的一向作风
谁,谁扔俺一脑袋瓜子烂蕃茄?!

orchi

我说浊酒，如果这样的美男站在你面前（这个这个，他穿了多少我们先不讨论 ），你还能有暴打的念头偶就pf你，估计你是想着不暴keng一通才浪费吧。。。。。。

月月

浊大说得吓人罢了，要真把开花扔你面前，你舍得虐他？恐怕自己就先晕了[em00][em00]

浊酒

汗,楼上两位秦耐滴,放心,俺晕是绝对不晕,那多浪费时间啊

俺肯定抓紧宝贵时间,发扬一不怕死二不怕苦,有条件要上没有条件创造条件也要上的革命精神,不惜抛头颅洒热血,对着某开花,占便宜没够一通个够本

汗,表行了,女狼本色暴露,会吓坏小MM

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-5-13 1:58:54编辑过]

月月

浊大，咳咳，克制啊克制，没吓坏小MM,先吓坏小开花，开花可不是一般的害羞啊，偶就稀饭他害羞的小样子~

zq

到那时候还轮得到浊酒大吗，一帮色女早把ORLI尸了！[em06][em06][em06][em11][em11][em11]哦哦，不好不好，偶这样子才真的回吓坏小MM门，赶快逃吧！

linita

以下是引用orchi在2004-5-13 1:03:09的发言：


[B]I must say, however, BRAVO ORLANDO BLOOM. Although I did not appreciate the
Legolas revival in the end (which I can forgive since it was part of the
story... however it just didn't fit), ...........
虽然我不喜欢（影片最后）他最后逃脱了,..........

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-5-13 1:38:04编辑过]

楼主,这句话的意思好象不是这样子吧,那个小MM说她不欣赏影片最后的Paris表现的如同Legolas复活一样,就是说不喜欢他变的勇敢,和原著里懦弱的家伙不相符了.

orchi

啊，是哦，该打，早上还没睡醒翻的，kick myself

bellelai

以下是引用zq在2004-5-13 6:38:01的发言：
到那时候还轮得到浊酒大吗，一帮色女早把ORLI尸了！[em06][em06][em06][em11][em11][em11]哦哦，不好不好，偶这样子才真的回吓坏小MM门，赶快逃吧！

暴，偶看到有个尸字那句，就直接看成了：“一帮色女早把orli鞭尸了”……偶BT……今天下午下狂雨，一睡醒上来看到这个花痴到不行的贴，大喜！

浊大你理解的没错，那就是美丽到荒谬或者难以置信的意思！！不过那个词老外用很多，不算特别有新意的赞美了，呵呵……

PS：广州的MM想一起去看戏可以找偶

lovemode

剛看到的影評

http://www.ucsdguardian.org/cgi-bin/hiatus?art=2004_05_13_01

Orlando Bloom is fine in the expanded-just-for-him role of Paris, but it seems like the writers didn’t know exactly how to handle him. Was he courageous or passionate or a lothario or what? He has a little bit of everything, and he has inner-conflict, which is nice, but how were the choices that he inevitably made influenced by his entire journey? It is difficult to buy the character.

lovemode

再一篇

http://romanticmovies.about.com/cs/troy/a/troy051304.htm

Orlando Bloom once again oozes animal magnetism. Even while playing the coward, Bloom is compelling and hard to dislike.

flyfrog

26楼的没太看懂。喜欢27楼的那个评论^_^

浊酒

26楼的,俺也没看太明白,不过看前半句像好话,后面就不明所发啦

Orlando Bloom once again oozes animal magnetism. Even while playing the coward, Bloom is compelling and hard to dislike.
这句好,俺喜欢

今天看到有个MM对TROY的看后想法
她一上来说:OB不够水准
往后一看,她通篇批评的不是OB,是PARIS这个人物如何如何招她反感
俺只能说:这位MM看得太投入,或说OB确实演出了PARIS应有的性格,让她把演员和角色视为一体,认为OB就是PARIS,就是那个让她反感的无担当懦弱男

其实,有些习惯OB演招人喜欢的英雄角色的MM,是受不了PARIS这个人物的
但如果开花把PARIS演成了个人见人爱的英雄,俺们就真要哭了

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-5-13 21:22:34编辑过]

lovemode

再一篇
看來不有少評論家都認為劇本寫砸了，尤其是對PARIS以及PARIS和HELEN間戀情的描寫

再來，這已經是我第Ｎ次看到評論說：Orlando Bloom was too damn pretty for the role
搞不懂，漂亮也有錯嗎？[em05][em05][em05]


http://www.eclipsemagazine.com/modules/news/article.php?storyid=967

Orlando Bloom, why was he in this? He was too damn pretty for the role, and Paris really didn't do anything to help the situation. In order for this film to work, the audience needs to feel connected to Paris and Helen, and I didn't buy their romance, and worse, I kept waiting for Paris to do something, anything, to prove his worth or love. He's the one who started the entire mess, and all he did was sit back, whine, and let Hector fight the battle. Again, I found it hard to care about the conflict when the principles didn't care themselves. Between Achilles and Paris, there's nothing tangible to really sink your teeth into.